
Start with the part that is against interest: most chest problems do not need a pulmonologist. A cough with fever, a chest infection, an ordinary flare of known asthma — a competent general physician manages these well, and sending everyone to a specialist would waste money and achieve nothing.
But there is a specific set of situations where a general consultation keeps ending in the same place, and a different kind of assessment is what moves things. Those are worth naming, because people tend to arrive either far too early or several years too late.
The clearest reasons to see a chest specialist
A cough that has lasted more than six to eight weeks without a clear explanation, especially after a trial of treatment has not worked.
Breathlessness that has not been explained. If you are more short of breath than you were a year ago and nobody has done a breathing test, that is the gap. Breathlessness has a long list of causes and most of them are distinguishable.
Asthma that is not controlled. Specifically: needing a reliever more than twice a week, waking at night, more than one course of steroid tablets a year, or any attack needing hospital care. Each of those means the treatment needs reassessing rather than repeating.
Suspected or confirmed COPD, at the point of diagnosis — because the diagnosis requires spirometry to confirm, and treatment set without it is often wrong in both directions.
Coughing blood. Any amount, once. This always warrants investigation.
An abnormal chest X-ray or CT — a nodule, scarring, a shadow, an effusion. See a spot on your lung scan.
Suspected lung cancer, or weight loss with respiratory symptoms.
TB that is not going as expected — not improving on treatment, drug resistance, drug reactions, or TB in a difficult site.
Interstitial lung disease, or any mention of fibrosis on a scan. These are specialist diagnoses and getting the subtype right determines the treatment.
Loud snoring with daytime sleepiness, or witnessed pauses in breathing. Obstructive sleep apnoea is very common, very treatable and almost never diagnosed without someone thinking of it. See snoring and daytime sleepiness.
Recurrent chest infections, particularly in the same part of the lung, which raises the question of bronchiectasis or an obstruction.
Occupational exposure to dust, fumes, stone or asbestos, with any respiratory symptom — dust at work explains why this is missed so often.
Before a procedure like a bronchoscopy, a pleural tap or a biopsy, or when one has been suggested.
The signs that you should have come sooner
Said plainly, because these are the common patterns:
- You have been on antibiotics three or four times for the same cough without a chest X-ray ever being done.
- You have had asthma for ten years and never had a breathing test. This is extremely common. Asthma diagnosed on history alone is sometimes not asthma, and COPD treated as asthma is treated wrongly.
- You are using a reliever inhaler daily and have no preventer, or are not taking it.
- You have had a cough for months and the explanation keeps being "allergy" without anyone testing for allergy.
- Somebody mentioned "old TB" or "a spot" on a scan years ago and nothing was followed up.
- You were told you have COPD because you smoke and cough, without spirometry.
When it is not a specialist you need
It is equally worth saying:
- An acute chest infection in an otherwise well person — a physician handles this.
- A cold, or a cough of a few days.
- Well-controlled asthma on a stable regimen — an annual review is enough.
- Breathlessness that is clearly cardiac — that is a cardiologist, though the two often need sorting out together.
- A routine pre-employment or visa chest X-ray.
Go to a hospital now, not to an appointment
Some things are not a referral question:
- Severe breathlessness, or breathlessness at rest that is getting worse
- Chest pain with breathlessness, or either with fainting
- Blue or grey lips
- Coughing a large amount of blood
- A child struggling to breathe — drawing in at the ribs or neck, too breathless to speak or feed, or gone quiet after being noisy
What to bring, so the visit is worth making
This genuinely changes how much a consultation achieves.
- Every old report and every old film — the actual X-ray and CT images, not just the typed reports. Comparison answers questions nothing else can.
- All your inhalers and devices, physically. Not a list. A large part of the appointment is often watching you use them, and inhaler technique is wrong far more often than anyone admits.
- A list of your medicines, with doses, including anything from another doctor and anything you buy yourself.
- Your work history, if there has been any dust, fume, chemical or stone exposure.
- Smoking history — how much, how long, when stopped.
- A timeline. When it started, what makes it better or worse, what has been tried.
- Peak flow readings, if you have been asked to keep them.
What a first consultation actually involves
So that it is not an unknown, and so you can judge whether it was done properly.
The history takes the longest, and does the most. When symptoms started, how they have changed, what makes them better and worse, what has been tried and what happened. Then the things people do not expect to be asked: your job and what you handle, your home — cooking fuel, damp, pets, smoke — your smoking history in detail, your other conditions and every medicine you take. A good chest consultation spends more time on this than on the stethoscope.
Examination. Breathing rate and effort, oxygen saturation, listening to the chest, and looking at the things that go with lung disease — finger clubbing, ankle swelling, lymph nodes, the state of the nose and throat.
Inhaler technique, if you use one. You will be asked to demonstrate with your own device, which is why bringing them matters.
Spirometry, in most cases, before and after a reliever. Twenty minutes, no needles. What a spirometry test involves describes it in full.
A plan, in writing. You should leave knowing what the working diagnosis is, what each medicine is for, what to do on a bad day, and when you are being seen again. If you leave without those, ask before you go.
The tests you might leave with
Not everyone needs all of these, and a consultation that orders all of them for everyone is not doing it properly:
- Spirometry, usually on the day
- A chest X-ray, often on the day
- Blood tests — a full count, inflammatory markers, sometimes allergy
(IgE), vitamin D, sugar and thyroid
- Sputum tests, where infection or tuberculosis
is a question
- A CT scan, where the X-ray cannot answer the question —
chest X-ray or CT explains which
- Gas transfer and lung volumes, for breathlessness with normal spirometry
- A sleep study, for snoring with daytime sleepiness
- An ECG or echocardiogram, where the heart may be contributing
- A peak flow diary, which costs nothing and often decides the diagnosis
About second opinions
Asking for one is reasonable, and nobody should feel awkward about it — particularly before starting long treatment, before an invasive procedure, or when the diagnosis has not been explained in a way that makes sense to you.
Bring the full record when you do, including the reasoning you were given. A second opinion built on a partial history is often just a different guess.
The one thing that applies to everyone
Whatever the diagnosis, the highest-value action available to most people reading this is stopping smoking. No medicine on any page of this site does as much.
To arrange an assessment — bring the reports, the films and the inhalers — book a consultation or call 8563816000. The symptoms pages set out what each common complaint usually means and what tends to be tested.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a cough last before I see a specialist?
More than three weeks warrants investigation; more than six to eight weeks without a clear explanation, or after treatment has not worked, is a reasonable point for specialist assessment. Any cough with blood, weight loss, fever or breathlessness should be seen sooner.
I have had asthma for years. Do I need to see anyone?
If it is well controlled on a stable regimen, an annual review is enough. If you need a reliever more than twice a week, wake at night, have had more than one course of steroid tablets in a year, or have never had a breathing test, it is worth a specialist assessment.
What should I bring to the appointment?
Old reports and the actual X-ray and CT images, all your inhalers and devices physically rather than a list, your medicines with doses, your work and smoking history, and a timeline of symptoms. This is the difference between one useful visit and three partial ones.
Is it rude to ask for a second opinion?
No, and it is reasonable before starting long-term treatment, before an invasive procedure, or when the diagnosis has not been explained in a way that makes sense. Bring the complete record, including the reasoning you were given.
When should I go straight to hospital instead?
Severe breathlessness or breathlessness at rest that is worsening, chest pain with breathlessness, fainting, blue or grey lips, coughing a large amount of blood, or a child struggling to breathe. These are emergencies, not appointments.
